Facts about Acoustical Treatments
|
The following is a list of common sound problems found in all worship spaces and churches. If your church has already replaced it's sound system three of four times already and tried different designs, perhaps the problem is acoustical. You should get your church tested before you buy another sound system. |
Problem | Cause and Repair |
Dead Spots | Sound System |
Congregational Singing | Acoustics |
Bass Player can't hear himself | Acoustics |
Gain before feedback | Sound System Design & Acoustics |
Intelligibility | Sound System Design & Acoustics |
Bass Player plays too loud | Acoustics |
Drummer is being picked up by all the open mics | Drum Placement & Acoustics |
Drummers can't hear themselves in the monitors or other musicians | Acoustics |
Monitor spills into the audience area | Acoustics |
Reinforcing the choir | Acoustics |
Choir can't hear themselves | Acoustics |
The Preach or minister or Priest hear themselves so loud they keep lowering their voices | Acoustics |
The Pipe Organ or Electronic Organ is too loud | Acoustics |
Sub Woofer are playing 3 to 9dB lower in level and often distort or clip | Acoustics |
Too much distortion from the sound system | Under powered system and acoustics |
Everyone has to stand within 10 inches of a mic or else feedback | System design and Acoustics |
Church attendance seems to be declining all the time and we have a great sound system | demographic and/or Acoustics |
As you can see, it is not enough to just install and operate a great sound
system. You have to have a way to manage the air in the room. Before any
sound system can sound great, before you can move forward in improving
the worship experience, you have to manage the reflections in the room.
Manage the sequencing of sound and manage the frequency response of the
room and the results will be immediately apparent. Taking care of these
three vital issues will change the worship experience of the church members
almost instantly. When your church is ready to take the next step in it's worship experience, look for a single step solution that addresses all of these problem. These problems are often fixed for less than the cost of upgrading or replacing the speaker system of most churches in existing church and is often free when planning new churches. |
The truth is, the most you can do with other room shapes is make them as usable as possible. You can make any room shape perform almost as good as a rectangle but these rooms will never “sound” like a rectangle. Every room has its own unique sound but few people get to hear it.
A rectangle room used sideways will never sound as good as a room used
lengthwise.
------------------------------
Some churches are in such denial about their acoustical problems that they
would rather teach the
church members Sign Language.
--------------------------------
Some churches are in such denial about their acoustical problems that they
would rather keep buying
new sound systems for minor gains at 3 times the cost of making acoustical
changes to fix the sound.
--------------------------------
Some churches are in such denial about their acoustical problems that they
rather build another
new church without acoustical help and hope the results will be different.
(which is how their existing church was built!)
--------------------------------
Some churches are in such denial about their acoustical problems that they
would let the church split.
--------------------------------
Nothing gets in the way of hearing the gospel more than the invisible and
hidden dangers
between the pulpit and the audience.
--------------------------------
Nothing gets in the way of hearing the gospel more than the invisible and
hidden dangers
between the sound system speakers and the audience.
--------------------------------
Nothing gets in the way of understanding the worship and music more than
the invisible and hidden dangers
between the sound system speakers and the audience.
-------------------------------
If you build a car without an engine, it will look nice but it won’t be
able to go anywhere.
If you build a church without acoustics, it can’t contribute to the community
it is supposed to serve.
------------------------------
Get your hearing tested for free. If you have an iPad, iPod or iPhone, you can test your hearing with a free App. It is good enough to confirm whether if you have a hearing problem and whether you should be getting professional help.
The software is from Unitron and they make hearing aids. So while some people think that this is just a sales marketing tool, and it very well may be, but it matches a hearing test of mine done in a proper lab hours apart. That is good enough to decide who should be behind a mixer and making adjustments during worship.
What I have also done is use this test for people who persistently ask
me to turn things up – even when they have sat in different places. When
everything is working properly and I know the sound system is passing the
STI speech intelligibility test, I will ask the person to take the test.
Be gentle and kind when asking people to take the test. When people discover
that they need help, setting them off in getting their hearing back often
gives them back their life too. The App is called “U-Hear”
------------------------------------
If experiencing poor sound in church could be measured as pain and people
are not complaining about it, it could be because they don't consider taking
10 extra strength pain killers per worship service as overdosing.
Joseph De Buglio Jan 2013
- The Bible gives us the best plan for church acoustics that also allows
for
the best sound system performance possible. (Dec, 2012)
- It is easy to fix the acoustics good enough to make a sound system work
better but for the same cost you can make all of the worship service sound
better. (Dec, 2012)
- All Sound Systems are like magnifying glasses for the room acoustics.
(Nov 2012)
- If your Worship space performs properly, so will the sound system give
a great performance.
- If the worship space doesn't perform well, no sound system can make a
bad room sound good. (Oct 2012)
- If you have replaced your sound system two or more times in the last
15 years, you will most likely have to fix the room first before you will
be able to get any significant sound system performance improvements.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From St. Margaret Mary Catholic Church in Winter Park Florida August 27
2012
A member told Fr. Walsh, “Either the sound is getting better, or my hearing
has miraculously improved.”
Another member gave one of the ushers his hearing assistance device and
said, “Take this, someone else might be able to use it now.”
I have only heard folks saying they could hear more clearly than ever and
that the treatment aesthetically makes the place feel comfortably smaller,
not so big and antiseptic.
Example page 1 and 2 |
Example Page 3 and 4 |
Example Page 5, 6, and 7 |
Example page 8 and 9 |
Projects in Progress |
Projects Past and Present |
Church Tips Updated 2006 |
New Church Buildings |
Seven Days PDF 3 month Update |
CAPS™ A church acoustical standard |
Telephone Star (*) Codes |
PPD Panels Pressure Phase Diffusers |
Kingston Road United Church PDF |
For consulting assistance, please send an email asking for our PDF information file package that will be emailed to you. Please include the following:
Free Telephone Assistance from - 10:am to 6pm EST |
The ocean of air between the pulpit and the listener has many invisible
perils. The biggest danger is when sound is on it's journey, destructive reflections
amplified by the sound system often changes the sounds of the words. This always changes the meaning of the message. Joseph De Buglio April 16 2012
When standing at the pulpit at your church and the sound system is off,
do you speaker louder or quieter?
When you turn the sound system on, do you speak just as loud or quieter?
If you answer quieter to either of these two questions, you most likely
have a major acoustical problem.
October 22, 2011
"All churches are unique. Even when two churches are built alike, they will both be different and
they will sound different because no two congregations are alike and they
will always want to personalize a new building design. All churches have the same special requirements. All churches have the same basic requirements and some have advanced requirements. These requirements are not optional as they are the foundation of what
is needed to hear and participate in a large space. Management of sound in the church is to always achieve the same goals regardless
of the room shape, size and materials built from. All churches want the
same results whether the sound is amplified or not. All churches are unique.
All churches want to be unique yet they all want the same results - to
hear speech and music clearly."
Is this possible!!!
It is possible and it has been done.
(c) Joseph De Buglio 2011
So you dial in a great mix when the praise team or choir rehearsed before
worship service. Everything sounds great. Everything sounds grand for the
first song. Then about half way through the 2nd or 3rd song, the music
starts to sound horrible. The balance of the vocals and instruments are
way off. It seems like the vocals and any instruments using open mics are
being turn down or the electronic instruments were turned up. Seconds later,
you hear the onset of feedback or ringing in the sound system. But how!
Everything was sounding so good just a few seconds ago. HELP!!!!
Is this sort of scenario happening almost every week? Are you finding that
after a few songs the performance of the sound system has changes? Are
you struggling with getting decent gain before feedback, even with the
pastor's headset mic? Is this a sound system problem and do we have to
upgrade again? If the sound at your church changes during worship or from
week to week, it's not you (the sound operator); it's not your sound system;
it's not the performers, the choir or the people speaking through the sound
system. 99% of the time the problem is a result of the room.
The sequence of reflections, the storage of energy in a confined space
and the large flat surfaces in a worship space are all susceptible to climate
changes. When people sing, they change the humidity and temperature of
the worship space. Sound travels faster through water than through the
air. When you rehearsed before worship the room had a lower level of humidity.
As people started coming into the worship space, already the temperature
started going up and churches with air conditioning, most systems are not
able to keep the room stable during worship. When the people start to sing,
the humidity of the room changes and the threshold of feedback shift from
being stable to unstable. When this happens all you can do is lower the
level of the sound system. Micro-managing each and every microphone changes
the mix balance and things go downhill from there. Just turn the master
fader down and leave the mix alone. It will keep the glaring eyes down
to a dull roar.
The fix is - as you can guess - is fix the acoustics. A room with the acoustics
as was in Solomon's temple will give your worship experience a stable sound system and an improvement
in the congregational singing too.
In my books, a church without acoustical treatment or has built in features
is a church that has not been completed. Another way of saying it, a church
is not finished its construction until the acoustics are done. What kind
of acoustics? Any system that can give you at least 12 of the 14 item listed
below.
Question: When is there too much bass in a church?
Answer: When everyone else can hear it and the performers can't.
There are two main approaches to acoustics in churches.
One approach is call "sound system acoustics." That is when the acoustical fix is designed to get more performance from
a sound system. This often means going overboard with a single action treatment
which often "kills the room" or they provide just enough treatment
to get enough additional performance to justify a sound system upgrade.
While the sound system does perform better, it is most likely not working
as well as it could and often the worship experience is reduced somewhat.
In many instances the worship experience, especially the congregational
singing is reduced a lot.
The second approach is called "Complete church acoustics." That is when the acoustical fix brings the room up to peak performance
for almost all aspects of worship. In one step the fix is designed to make
the room perform well for;
- congregational singing
- the praise and worship team
- cutting the stage noise down
- improving the sound of the choir and for the choir to hear themselves
- improves the ability for the praise team to hear each other whether using IEM or floor monitors
- assisting the ministers to hear themselves better
- hearing speech without a sound system to a larger area of the room without the sound system (up to 80 ft in most rooms)
- people with hearing aids to hear further without assistance. If you can hearing well at 10 ft normal conversation in a quiet room, the church acoustics should be just as good. (depending on the type of hearing loss you may have.)
- any acoustical performances such as the piano, the pipe organ or digital organ, guitars and orchestra instruments.
- improving the bass response for all musical instruments and amplified bass
- sub woofers will see a 3 to 6dB boost
- drum kits (reducing or eliminating the need for drum shields.)
- tremendous gain before feedback
- Less distortion from the sound system
- Able to mix from any seat in the church
A room that can do all of this would be an excellent worship space that
can double as a multi-purpose worship space able to perform well for all
styles of preaching, worship and music. The big question is, which acoustical
fix will cost less?
The two approaches to church acoustics often cost the same. If your sound
system company is recommending an acoustical fix for your church to improve
the sound system performance and they are not offering to fix any or most
these problems at the same time, then you could be compromising your church
further and doing more harm to the spiritual growth of your church. Gaining
a better sound system at the expense of congregational singing can undo
everything your minister and elders are trying to do. All of your acoustical
and sound system problems should be fixed in one step and we have the most
experience in keeping that promise.
A Classic Church and Cathedral - Kingston Rd United Church, Completed 2009. You can have conversations with
people at 130 ft in this room and the RT60 is over 1.6 seconds.
In 1987, this project included real projection, high powered subwoofers,
over 25 performers on stage and 56 channel Soundcraft mixer.
We work on projects that have a wide range of budgets. Ready made solutions
are often high cost. If your church wants to offer some volunteer help,
the cost of fixing a worship space becomes much more affordable. Here are some examples of projects with very limited budgets. For each church the worship space was changed from a hostile non musical, low intelligibility space to a high quality space that has an almost ideal balance of musical performance with great speech intelligibility whether the sound system is on or off. |
JdB Sound Acoustics does not sell audio equipment, acoustical panels or do installations. | E-mail address is - jdb@jdbsound.com PH. 519-582-4443 |
A congregation isn't passive like the audience in a theatre or concert
hall. Worshipers play a vital, active role. Churches should be an environment
that connects the people to each other and supports their participation
in the worship and the message. |